Glossy Pop Newsletter: ‘Not So Pretty’ Drives TikTokers to question talc and throw out their makeup

All merchandise featured on Glossy Pop are independently chosen by our editorial workforce. However, whenever you purchase one thing by means of our retail hyperlinks, we might earn an affiliate fee.

In April, HBO debuted a brand new docuseries, “Not So Pretty.” Narrated by Keke Palmer and damaged up into 4 episodes, every episode focuses on a distinct section of the sweetness business (“Makeup,” “Nails,” “Skin” and “Hair” are the titles of every present).

The first episode, “Makeup,” focuses on talc. Talc is a mineral discovered incessantly in magnificence and private care merchandise, starting from eyeshadow to, infamously, Johnson & Johnson’s Baby Powder. Some talc is contaminated with asbestos, a identified carcinogen that may trigger most cancers.

As Popsugar reported, “In 2018, Johnson & Johnson was sued by 22 ladies who claimed the corporate’s child powder contained asbestos-contaminated talc, which lead them to develop most cancers. In the case, the corporate was ordered to pay over $4 billion in damages.”

In the 35-minute episode, “Not So Pretty” filmmakers interviewed individuals like Corrin Ortillo, who was identified with mesothelioma, a tumor attributable to inhaling asbestos. As a viewer, it’s pure to empathize with a topic’s expertise. The info revealed concerning the presence of asbestos in makeup additionally elicits concern for oneself and family members that use makeup. The episode “Makeup” invokes an understanding that governing our bodies (just like the FDA) individuals assume must be ensuring stuff like this “doesn’t occur,” aren’t at all times doing so.

A ensuing hashtag, #notsopretty has since spawned 19.6 million views on TikTook. In lots of the TikTook posts, creators document themselves throwing away heaps of makeup, presumably after reevaluating their stashes since watching the episode and feeling pushed to eradicate talc from their routines.

Victoria Morgan, 25, is without doubt one of the customers who threw away her makeup. In a 44-second video, she tosses merchandise from Anastasia Beverly Hills, Laura Mercier and Urban Decay, to title a number of. While purging, she declares, “you’re finished,” to every because it goes within the trash. “I’m an enormous documentary fan, and Keke Palmer was narrating the present,” Morgan mentioned. She advised Glossy, “I used to be shocked, I had no concept talc was utilized in makeup. I knew concerning the Johnson & Johnson lawsuit, however I by no means imagined talc was getting used within the merchandise I used for thus a few years.”

“I removed about half of my makeup. As I seemed in my trash can, I knew I’d finally see a creator doing one thing related, so I took every little thing out and took out my telephone [to record the process]. It was a great way to present simply what number of high-end merchandise comprise talc. Where is change when there isn’t any outrage,” Morgan mentioned. Influencer Remi Bader commented on Morgan’s publish, “I had a talc-free section and used cowl fx which I appreciated. But most issues have talc so I gave up 😳” Clean magnificence model Saie noticed the ’Not So Pretty’ dialog as a chance. “This seems like a job for us,” the model commented, suggesting itself as a talc-free choice.

Consumers are proper to be involved, to an extent. The FDA could possibly be a “little bit stricter when it comes to the way it regulates cosmetics,” mentioned Javon Ford, a beauty chemist who posted a contrasting response to the documentary. Ford, who has 184,000 followers on TikTook mentioned, “Y’all do not need to throw out your talc-based makeup.”

The documentary, Ford mentioned, presents the problem as overly black and white. However, “like most issues in life, it’s a spectrum. It’s at all times the dose that makes the poison,” he mentioned.

“To [the filmmakers], any quantity of asbestos within the product is taken into account harmful,” Ford defined, noting that in beauty testing usually there’s a threshold that’s thought-about acceptable. “[The filmmakers] aren’t on the lookout for the absence of asbestos normally. Realistically, you possibly can’t keep away from it as a result of it’s a pure compound. It’s going to be current. To blindly say to others that asbestos is poisonous isn’t useful from a sensible standpoint.”

To additional complicate a posh subject, alternate options for talc in cosmetics embrace mica, which comes with its personal set of points. Refinery29 known as mining for mica the sweetness business’s “darkest secret” in 2019 as a result of it’s typically obtained through youngster labor. Another substitute, silica, “may cause silicosis (a lung illness) in case you breathe in an excessive amount of,” Ford mentioned.

When Ford acquired questions from involved viewers of the documentary, he acknowledged individuals had been really feeling scared by what they noticed. That was his essential subject with the docuseries, he mentioned. “It must be making individuals question issues and need to do their personal analysis, it shouldn’t come to a conclusion in and of itself.’”

Still, customers have to determine the place to draw the road for themselves.

“Regardless of what label is on a product, ‘clear’ or ‘inexperienced,’ at all times patch take a look at a beauty for per week to make sure that your physique will react to it properly. You can have an allergic response, and it may be a wonderfully secure product by fashionable definitions, and your physique simply gained’t prefer it,” Ford suggested. “None of [these products] must be [inhaled].”

“This is a troublesome subject to touch upon, because it’s nonetheless in growth,” mentioned Emmy Ketcham, co-founder and chief product officer at Experiment. “From a formulator’s perspective, it’s necessary to vet a provider’s analytical strategies, particularly for components with identified contaminant points. Talc shouldn’t be demonized as an ingredient, because it’s largely contaminant-free, however it’s robust for a shopper to know what’s secure and what’s not with out entry to the uncooked materials documentation.”

Instead, her hope is that the FDA will expedite updating the steering on asbestos testing so “we are able to resume utilizing talc with out concern.”

Launches to know

Olive & June x elf Moonstone Shine Nail Art Gems, $9.00 

This summer season, we’re bedazzling every little thing — nails included — and Olive & June and elf are making it straightforward thanks to this new collab.

Dr. Barbara Sturm, Microbiotic Collection, $35-100

The luxurious skincare line is making a play for a youthful (and uh, much less rich) clients with its new four-piece assortment, wealthy in pre and probiotics for stronger pores and skin. If in want of a brand new spot remedy, attempt the very well-named “Ultimate Stinky Pimple Treatment” — store it right here. 

Holifrog Utopia Microflora Toner, $44

Fortifying the pores and skin barrier continues to be a spotlight of manufacturers and customers — and this new toner (not the strip-your-skin form) is correct on pattern with a bevy of barrier-boosting components — hypochlorous acid, apple cider vinegar, fermented honey, and pre and probiotics.

Innbeautyproject Retinol Remix, $48

We consider retinol as efficient, important, scientifically-proven…however not enjoyable. With its newest launch, Innbeautyproject seeks to make skincare’s most famous ingredient somewhat extra playful, with out compromising efficacy. The system consists of peptides and tranexamic acid too, all of which work to agency and brighten pores and skin.

Pat McGrath, Rose 001 The Essence, $86

Any launch by Dame Pat McGrath is a extremely anticipated one, so you possibly can think about the thrill as she introduces her first skincare product — a dual-phase essence that smells like a bouquet of roses. Naomi Campbell fronts the marketing campaign and is an early fan.  “I wouldn’t use anything. The glow, the luminosity, the hydration, it’s unparalleled. It’s perfection,” she mentioned in a press launch.

Kora Organics Active Algae Lightweight Moisturizer, $56

Miranda Kerr just lately added this light-weight, refillable moisturizer to her assortment. In the jewel-like jar, a plethora of natural components like inexperienced tea, Alpine rose, inexperienced algae and Swiss glacier water work collectively to soothe, nourish, and, after all, moisturize pores and skin.

Charlotte Tilbury Quick & Easy Makeup, $75

Never has one thing formed like a field of cigarettes been so stylish. This really revolutionary little field from Charlotte Tilbury consists of the naked necessities for a less-than-5-minute face — an eyeshadow stick, a lip/cheek stick, and a highlighter stick. Getting prepared has – true to its title — by no means been so fast and straightforward.

Inside our protection

Hairstylist and model founder Andrew Fitzsimons takes to Instagram in protection of Roe v. WadeThe subsequent frontier of inclusive hair is textured hair stylingThe menopause class is heating up

Reading record

We shouldn’t glorify Kim Kardashian’s Met Gala crash food plan

SZA’s Crocs collaboration is a few woody goodness — see picturesIn 2022, it’s nonetheless impossibly laborious to be a fats content material creator on-line

Recommended For You

About the Author: Jessica