Indie Beauty Brand Is Suing Lisa Frank Over Failed Makeup Line

Indie magnificence model Glamour Dolls is suing Lisa Frank Inc. after a failed make-up collaboration.
Glamour Dolls says Lisa Frank Inc. dedicated fraud, defamation, and breach of contract.
The model is now in search of compensation for “direct hurt, punitive damages,” and extra.
Visit Insider’s homepage for extra tales.

An unbiased magnificence model is suing Lisa Frank Inc. after the 2 firms did not collaborate on a make-up line, angering hundreds of followers within the course of.Glamour Dolls, a New Jersey-based model, began a Kickstarter marketing campaign in 2017 to fund a Lisa Frank-themed make-up line that will honor the model’s colourful cartoons that have been common within the ’80s and ’90s.Though the marketing campaign raised over $370,000 from greater than 5,000 magnificence lovers, the gathering by no means got here to fruition. Instead, choose objects have been offered by way of Hot Topic and Ipsy, and a separate Lisa Frank make-up line was launched by Morphe in November 2020.Now, Glamour Dolls is suing Lisa Frank Inc. for fraud, defamation, breach of contract, and extra. Representatives for Lisa Frank Inc. didn’t instantly reply to Insider’s latest request for remark.

A submit shared by Morphe (@morphebrushes)
Glamour Dolls says in its criticism — which was filed by Glamour Dolls’ attorneys on May 27 and considered by Insider — that Lisa Frank Inc. not solely did not ship its aspect of the licensing settlement the 2 events agreed upon in 2016, however that the corporate additionally shared lies concerning the scenario with the press.Specifically, the indie model stated within the criticism that it is paid Lisa Frank Inc. roughly $770,000 to this point, however that almost all clients and retailers by no means acquired their orders as a result of Lisa Frank Inc. “deliberately and blatantly stymied the method at each doable juncture.”According to the criticism, Lisa Frank Inc. did so by “refusing” to offer art work and well timed approvals and disapproving pattern merchandise.Glamour Dolls additionally stated in its criticism that over the course of its relationship to Lisa Frank Inc., the model made false statements about Glamour Dolls and “pressured early fee” of royalties Lisa Frank Inc. had not but earned in order that it might deceitfully cancel its contract with the indie model.

“As a results of such illegal refusal, GDI [Glamour Dolls Inc.] was disadvantaged of the power to ‘use and promote’ the overwhelming majority of the Licensed Products for which it had paid royalties,” the criticism says. “In impact, defendants reaped the numerous financial advantages of the license agreements whereas deliberately and systematically stopping GDI from receiving the identical.”After doing so, in response to the criticism, Lisa Frank Inc. shared “false and disparaging accusations and statements” with the press, and named Insider particularly. In November 2020, Insider spoke with quite a few magnificence followers who stated they have been upset to study that Lisa Frank had collaborated with Morphe on a make-up line after they beforehand backed the Glamour Dolls Kickstarter marketing campaign and by no means acquired make-up or refunds.While some followers informed Insider they have been upset with Glamour Dolls, the bulk stated they have been largely disenchanted in Lisa Frank Inc., and felt as if the model was ignoring what occurred with its unique, failed make-up line. One magnificence fan informed Insider that she felt Lisa Frank Inc. “discarded” the Kickstarter backers “like trash.”

Backers left feedback on the Glamour Dolls Kickstarter web page as lately as final week.

Kickstarter

Now, Glamour Dolls cofounder Peter Georgotas is hoping that his firm’s lawsuit may also help give backers a way of what actually occurred between the 2 manufacturers.”We’re past grateful, personally and professionally, for everybody who continued to help and imagine in us as we labored with our attorneys to get this lawsuit filed,” Georgotas stated in an announcement despatched to Insider. “In our continued efforts for transparency, we’ve got a hyperlink to the total criticism accessible right here.” “As the case strikes ahead and data is disclosed, backers and clients will get a extra full image of the circumstances across the Glamour Dolls collaboration with Lisa Frank,” he continued. “Ultimately, we imagine justice will likely be served and are excited to refocus on our mission of making enjoyable, vegan, cruelty-free merchandise and experiences for purchasers everywhere in the world.”Previously in November 2020, representatives for Lisa Frank Inc. stated in an announcement emailed to Insider that Glamour Dolls “utterly failed” to reside as much as its settlement. 

“After many months of pushing Glamour Dolls to reside as much as its contractual obligations and ship merchandise — to our followers and retailers that ordered merchandise — Lisa Frank Inc. reached the purpose of exasperation, terminated the settlement with Glamour Dolls, and contacted the Federal Government,” the assertion stated. “To say we’re disenchanted by the occasions that transpired on account of this license is an understatement.”According to the brand new criticism from Glamour Dolls, the above assertion labeled the indie model as a “corrupt, untrustworthy and incompetent enterprise with substandard merchandise,” and induced the corporate “great harm to its enterprise fame.”Glamour Dolls is now in search of “compensation for direct hurt, punitive damages, and disgorgement of defendants’ earnings,” in response to the criticism, although it is unclear how a lot cash precisely the corporate is in search of.